For a first leadership role
How a new manager holds a difficult conversation
A method for the conversation a new manager has been putting off. Prepare the example, open on the work, stay with that example when emotions rise, and finish with one next action. The live workshop is where you practice it. The program is where the habit gets reviewed.
The talk
What is a difficult conversation for a new manager?
A difficult conversation is the talk a new manager has been putting off: a performance issue, a tension, or a miss that keeps getting ignored. The live workshop gives a method for preparing, opening, and finishing that talk so the issue gets handled. Everyday notes on one fresh example are a shorter talk. This page is the one people avoid.
Difficult Conversations is a live session that gives managers a practical method for preparing, opening, and finishing the conversations most people avoid, so performance issues and tensions get resolved instead of ignored. This page writes that method down for a person in a first leadership role. It is the talk that has already sat: the miss everyone can see, the tension nobody names, the standard that slipped and was left there.
A note on one fresh example, given close to the work, is a shorter talk. Use that when the work just happened and you can still point at it. Use this page when the talk has been avoided and the same miss is about to happen again. Both stay on the work. Neither is a warning, a termination, or an accommodation decision. Those follow the procedure the company already has.
The buyer for this page is the HR leader, the operations leader, or the general manager who just promoted an hourly person and can already see the talk that person will dodge. The floors are a plant, a store or grocery department, a guest floor or an attraction, and a warehouse. The supervisor training program is the program for the supervisor role. First-time manager training is the same door when the role has another name.
Words you can say when the miss has already sat
"The same miss has been on the board for three shifts, and I have not said it to you. The next crew started behind each time. What did you see? Before the next shift, the board names the miss and who owns the fix. I will look at the board with you then."
Words that put the person on the defensive
"You always do this." "You do not care about the next crew." "Everyone is frustrated with you." None of those can be checked. Replace each one with the task, the time, and what happened. If you cannot point to one example, you are not ready to open.
Before you open
How does a new manager prepare for a difficult conversation?
Prepare before you open. Write the one issue, one example a camera would have caught, the effect on the work, and the next action. Name who handles safety, employee relations, and urgent customer issues if this is not a practice conversation. Pick a private place close to the work. Leave older examples out of the opening.
The workshop teaches a preparation framework for difficult discussions. On paper it is short. Write four lines before you speak: the one issue, the example, the effect on the work, and the next action you want. If you need a fifth line, it is the question you will ask, which is some version of what they saw. Then stop writing. A longer note becomes a speech, and a speech is how an avoided talk stays avoided.
Decide, before you need it, who handles safety concerns, employee relations, and urgent customer issues. If the talk is one of those, you are not preparing a practice conversation. You are using the company path. Name that person while the day is ordinary, not in the doorway of the office.
Pick the place before you pick the words. A guest, a customer, or the rest of the crew in earshot means you move. Say where and when, then keep that time. Close to the work still matters after a delay: the next shift is better than a meeting three weeks out. You do not have to wait for a standing meeting. If one is already on the calendar and it is private, it can hold the talk. The calendar is not the method.
Leave older examples out of the opening. If three things have been sitting, pick the one that will happen again next. The others wait until you have a fresh example of each. A stack feels like a verdict. One current example is something the person can answer.
- One issue, in one sentence, that you have been putting off.
- One example: the task, the time, and what a camera would have caught.
- The effect on the next crew, the guest, the customer, or the rework.
- The next action, the owner, and when you will look again.
- A private place. If this is a formal matter, the company path instead of this script.
The opening
How do you open a difficult conversation without putting someone on the defensive?
Open with the work, not a label. Name the task, the time, and what happened, then the effect, then ask what they saw. Skip always, never, and a guessed motive. The live workshop teaches how to open without putting people on the defensive. If a guest, a customer, or the crew can hear, move before you start.
The workshop teaches how to open conversations without putting people on the defensive. The opening is the example, not a character judgment. "The board still said on time" is checkable. "You do not respect the next crew" is not. Say the task, the time, and what happened. Then the effect. Then ask what they saw, and leave room for the answer.
Skip always, never, and everyone. Skip a motive you guessed. Skip a comparison with a peer. If the person used to work beside you, keep the words on the work. Explain what the role now asks you to say. Do not pretend the relationship is unchanged, and do not make the relationship the topic. The topic is the example in front of you.
If anyone else can hear, move first. One sentence is enough to change rooms: "I want to talk about the board before you go. Not here." Then keep that time. Opening in front of the crew turns a correction into a public loss, and the next hard talk gets harder.
Ask them to describe what they saw before you add the next action. If you deliver all four lines without a pause, you did not open a conversation. You made an announcement. The announcement can wait until you have heard one sentence back.
Say this
- The task and the time.
- What the next person had to do because of it.
- What did you see?
- The next action, once they have answered.
Leave this out
- Always, never, and everyone.
- A motive you guessed.
- A list of old examples you did not raise at the time.
- A warning. That is a company procedure.
When it gets heated
What do you do when emotions run high in a difficult conversation?
Stay on the example. If the other person is upset, pause, repeat the task and the effect, and ask what they saw. Do not add older examples to win the point. The live workshop covers staying calm when emotions run high. If the facts stay disputed and the issue is formal, stop and follow the company procedure.
The workshop covers techniques for staying calm when emotions run high. Calm here is not a mood. It is staying on the example. If the other person is upset, pause. Repeat the task and the effect in the same words you opened with. Ask again what they saw. Do not raise your list of older examples to win the point. Adding them turns a correction into an argument.
If they saw a different fact, write that down. You may both be right about different parts of the task. Agree on what you will both look at next time: the board, the handoff, the first ten units, the guest who waited. If the facts stay disputed and the issue is formal, stop. Leave the floor and follow the company procedure. Do not keep the debate in front of the crew.
A new manager often still knows the task better than the title. That makes it easy to take the work back instead of finishing the talk. Taking the work back ends the emotion and leaves the issue where it was. The next action has to be something they can do, not something you will quietly do after they leave.
If you feel yourself collecting a speech, stop at the one example. You can look again the next time the work happens. You do not have to settle every tension in the building in one conversation.
- Pause. Do not fill the silence with a second example.
- Repeat the task and the effect. Ask what they saw.
- Write down a fact you had wrong.
- If the issue is now formal, stop and use the company path.
The close
How does a new manager finish a difficult conversation?
Finish with one next action, one owner, and a time you will look again. Ask them to say the next step in their own words. If they cannot, you do not have an agreement yet. After you leave, write the date, the task, what you observed, the effect, what they said, and when you will look again.
Finish with one next action, one owner, and a time you will look again. Ask them to say the next step in their own words. If they cannot say it, you do not have an agreement yet. Repeat the action once, in their words, and stop. The workshop follow-up is that look-again, not a second speech.
Write the note after you leave, not as a script you read at them. This form stays in the browser you are using. Nothing on it is saved. Keep confidential employee information out of any copy someone else will see. If the note might be shared, take the name off the example.
The note is a learning record. When you look again, compare the same task with what you wrote. If the next action happened, say so with the same shape: what you saw, the effect, what they would repeat. If it did not, use one fresh example. Do not reread the whole history. If the issue is now a conduct, safety, or employee relations matter, leave the note and follow the company procedure.
What this is not
What belongs in a company procedure instead of this conversation?
A practice conversation is not a substitute for established HR procedures. Safety, employee relations, and urgent customer issues go to the person the company named for them. Do not use this page for a warning, a termination, or an accommodation decision. The live workshop is where a new manager practices the talk people have been avoiding.
Some talks are not practice. A warning, a termination, an accommodation decision, a safety incident, and an employee relations issue follow the procedure the company already has. A practice conversation is not a substitute for those paths. Name the person who handles safety, employee relations, and urgent customer issues before you need them.
Difficult Conversations is the live workshop for the conversation people have been avoiding. It runs for two hours, with 25 seats, on Microsoft Teams. Each of the 16 workshop topics runs once a month, at 3:00 PM Eastern, 2:00 PM Central, noon Pacific. Use the workshop when you want to practice preparing, opening, and finishing with a facilitator watching. Use this page for the next real example.
Coaching Fundamentals is the live session on spotting a coaching moment in daily work, choosing how to lead that person, and running the conversation. The published session includes techniques for giving feedback that drives improvement. Come with one real example from the note above. It is not a replacement for the company procedure, and it is not this page.
The supervisor training program and first-time manager training are the program pages. The first 90 days after a promotion is the company plan around the new supervisor. The new manager checklist is what HR sets up. This page stays on the words of the difficult conversation.
Where to practice
Where does a new manager practice a difficult conversation?
Thrive runs the organization's talent development function. The price is flat per organization. Fundamentals of Leading People is the door for a first leadership role: four weeks, about two hours of live time a week, live on Microsoft Teams. Applied work on the real role is reviewed by our team. The Difficult Conversations workshop is the live practice.
Fundamentals of Leading People is four weeks, about two hours of live time a week, $1,000 per seat, on top of the platform band.
It is for people in their first leadership role or about to take one: supervisors promoted from the line, engineers who now manage, team leads who inherited a team. Built for people in their first year of leading. Live sessions, applied work on the participant's real job, 1-on-1 coaching, and a cohort. Sessions run live on Microsoft Teams.
Each week: a short theme film, a live session with a facilitator who has held the job, applied work on the participant's real role reviewed by our team, a 1-on-1, and a cohort debrief. The four themes, in order, are awareness of self and others, leading individuals, leading teams, and leadership skill building. Leading individuals is coaching, giving feedback that changes behavior, and the tough conversation you have been putting off: plan a real one and practice it live with a facilitator watching. The applied work is on the real role. It is reviewed by our team.
Participants who complete the four weeks and the applied work receive a Leadership Development Plan with their program badge. Coach Taylor is our AI practice coach. The applied work in programs is reviewed by our team. Your team owns priorities, reminders, and follow-up; scheduled reminders are not built yet.
Public cohorts are capped at 25 participants and mix companies. A company can send one person. Any program can also run as a private cohort for your company alone, using your situations as the applied work, on dates set with you. Private cohorts are priced per participant and quoted with the dates. There is no button that sells you a seat. The room is small enough that a person confirms every one of them, so you tell ARIA how many you need and we come back with the seats held. The platform is the part you can buy in a browser.
Thrive is not an LMS. It is a talent development function for companies of 50 to 2,500 people: live workshops and programs led by facilitators who have held the role, a growing course library with compliance included, and agents that run the administration, at one flat price per organization.
The platform is one flat price per organization by headcount: $3,990 a year for up to 100 employees, $7,990 for 101 to 500, and $14,990 for 501 to 2,500, every employee included. Annual billing is ten months charged for twelve months of access; monthly is $399, $799 and $1,499. Above 2,500 the price is set with you, not looked up.
Buy the function for the company. Buy the seat for the person who has to hold the conversation. Everyone else at a company on the platform still gets the workshops and the library at the same flat price. There is no per-seat platform charge.
John Ball Zoo has put 100+ first-time leaders through Fundamentals of Leading People.
Fundamentals of Leading People is four weeks, about two hours of live time a week, $1,000 per seat, on top of the platform band.
What a talent development function is
See pricing
Supervisor training program that runs on your real work
First-time manager training that runs on your real work
Customers
Talk to ARIA
Ask what you would ask us.
ARIA works the way a good first call works. She asks who is involved and what should change, recommends the closest starting point, quotes the real price, and hands you to a person when you want one.
Start with one of these
Prefer a person? Say so in the conversation and the team follows up, or use the contact page.
Questions
Questions about difficult conversations for a new manager.
Who is this difficult conversation guide for?
A person in a first leadership role who has been putting off a hard talk, and the HR, operations, or general manager who needs that talk to happen on a plant floor, in a store or grocery department, on a guest floor or at an attraction, or in a warehouse. The supervisor training page is the program. First-time manager training is the same door when the role is not called supervisor. This page is how to prepare, open, and finish the conversation.
What does the Difficult Conversations workshop cover?
Difficult Conversations is a live session that gives managers a practical method for preparing, opening, and finishing the conversations most people avoid, so performance issues and tensions get resolved instead of ignored. This page is that method in writing. The workshop is the live practice: 25 seats, on Microsoft Teams, for two hours. You work on a preparation framework, opening without putting people on the defensive, and staying calm when emotions run high.
When should the conversation happen if it has already been avoided?
Have it before the next time the work happens, in a place the rest of the crew, a guest, or a customer cannot hear. Do not wait for a perfect quiet day, and do not save a stack of old examples for one speech. Name the current example. If the next occurrence is the coming shift, that is the time to look again. A standing meeting can hold the talk. The meeting is not required.
How much does training for a difficult conversation cost?
The platform is one flat price per organization by headcount: $3,990 a year for up to 100 employees, $7,990 for 101 to 500, and $14,990 for 501 to 2,500, every employee included. Annual billing is ten months charged for twelve months of access; monthly is $399, $799 and $1,499. Above 2,500 the price is set with you, not looked up. Fundamentals of Leading People is four weeks, about two hours of live time a week, $1,000 per seat, on top of the platform band.
Who reviews applied work?
The applied work in programs is reviewed by our team. Your team owns priorities, reminders, and follow-up; scheduled reminders are not built yet.
Where does Fundamentals of Leading People fit?
It is the door for a first leadership role. Four weeks, about two hours of live time a week, $1,000 per seat, on top of the platform band. Leading individuals covers coaching, giving feedback that changes behavior, and the tough conversation you have been putting off. You plan a real one and practice it live with a facilitator watching. Applied work on the real role is reviewed by our team.
Do I need an LMS?
No. Thrive is not an LMS. An LMS stores content and records completions. It carries one of the jobs at most. The rest, the delivery, the follow-up, the coaching, the review, and the reporting, are the function. Thrive is a talent development function for companies of 50 to 2,500 people: live workshops and programs led by facilitators who have held the role, a growing course library with compliance included, and agents that run the administration, at one flat price per organization.